L. Sulla and L. Manlius Torquatus. 82 BC. AR Denarius (19mm, 4.27 g, 9h). Military mint moving with Sulla.

Electronic Auction 472
Lot: 257. Estimated: $ 200

Selections from the Andrew McCabe Collection, Silver

Sold For $ 300. This amount does not include the buyer’s fee.

Go to Live

L. Sulla and L. Manlius Torquatus. 82 BC. AR Denarius (19mm, 4.27 g, 9h). Military mint moving with Sulla. Helmeted head of Roma right / Sulla driving triumphal quadriga right, holding branch and reins; above, Victory flying left, crowning him with laurel wreath. Crawford 367/3; Sydenham 759; Manlia 7-8; Type as RBW –. Toned, struck from a clashed obverse die. Good VF.

From the Andrew McCabe Collection.

Clear die clash is visible on the obverse where the reverse exergual line and the letters L.SVL[LA] can be seen incuse before Roma’s head. A die clash between two incuse-engraved dies produces a raised feature on the damaged die and thus an incuse and reversed image on the as-struck coin. They are quite scarce to find so clear, and I have collected examples over the years, see CNG E-408, lots 423 and 431. Note also the scarcer reverse on a typically larger flan where the horse to the right on the coin is also to the right of the quadriga group. Crawford’s arrangement per obverse legend ignores the much bigger difference in the two reverse horse arrangements. The type with this quadriga sometimes come with faintly visible control marks scratched into the die that wear off over time, see Phillip Davis’ article “Control marks: Tiny letters, numbers or symbols on Roman Republican denarii offer collectors a brain-teasing challenge” in The Numismatist (Vol. 126, No. 8, August 2013), pp. 65-7. These numbers are above the horses or before or under the horses’ legs. Very close examination on this coin shows no confirmable trace, but they were so lightly engraved that they quickly wore off during die use, as indeed was likely the intention. From time to time I buy examples of this quadriga variety in order to examine the field for these elusive numbers. [Andrew McCabe]

Closing Date and Time: 15 July 2020 at 11:25:20 ET.

All winning bids are subject to an 18% buyer’s fee.